Can cereal be considered a soup?

[KSI Pastries 7 34]

Cereal is served cold, soup is served hot.

cereal is sweet, soup is savory

Cereal uses a normal spoon, soup uses a soup spoon

Cereal is for everyone, No soup for you

Thus, cereal is not soup!

 

On the other hand though porridge/oatmeal could be soup  

[Evade dragon 0]

Who would ever put crackers I cereal

[KSI Zordon 112]

1 hour ago, KSI Pastries 7 said:

Cereal is served cold, soup is served hot.

cereal is sweet, soup is savory

Cereal uses a normal spoon, soup uses a soup spoon

Cereal is for everyone, No soup for you

Thus, cereal is not soup!

 

On the other hand though porridge/oatmeal could be soup  

Gazpacho is a cold soup and is also kind of sweet. Furthermore, not all cereal is sweet. 

 

And have you ever tried eating cereal with a soup spoon? It's absolutely better than using a normy spoon.  

"That's all I have to say about that."

[KSI Uppish 7 525]

12 hours ago, KSI Zordon said:

Gazpacho is a cold soup and is also kind of sweet.

Therefore, Gazpacho = cereal. Settle down sir

[KSI Zordon 112]

8 minutes ago, KSI Uppish 7 said:

Therefore, Gazpacho = cereal. Settle down sir

Let's break this down into some basic math.

Soup ≥ Gazpacho ≤ Cereal

[KSI Kenta 16]

No lol

[KSI FatGuy 8]

Definitely not a soup

[KSI Zordon 112]

Cereal ≥ soup

[KSI Uppish 7 525]

4 hours ago, KSI Zordon said:

Cereal ≥ soup

Yes but what if you don’t have milk? Still a soup?

[KSI Zordon 112]

No it must have a milky base! 

[KSI Borgata 10]

By practice yes. It can be considered a soup. However, most soups are a fine mixture creating a homogeneous solution which is not *Easily* separated. Cereal, in most cases, can be easily separated again. While not a defining reason for cereal to not be soup I think it's important to establish they are, but they aren't. Same same; but different? Right?

[KSI Zordon 112]

Can one not Spoon the noodles Out of the broth?

20 hours ago, KSI Borgata said:

By practice yes. It can be considered a soup. However, most soups are a fine mixture creating a homogeneous solution which is not *Easily* separated. Cereal, in most cases, can be easily separated again. While not a defining reason for cereal to not be soup I think it's important to establish they are, but they aren't. Same same; but different? Right?

 

[KSI Borgata 10]

2 hours ago, KSI Zordon said:

Can one not Spoon the noodles Out of the broth?

 

I was more arguing the point of separating a good broth to being it's individual components (stock, seasoning, herbs, etc.) Sure you can spoon noodles out, but noodles are merely one small portion of the equation.

[KSI Courage 29]

lol nope